AFNI Message Board

Dear AFNI users-

We are very pleased to announce that the new AFNI Message Board framework is up! Please join us at:

https://discuss.afni.nimh.nih.gov

Existing user accounts have been migrated, so returning users can login by requesting a password reset. New users can create accounts, as well, through a standard account creation process. Please note that these setup emails might initially go to spam folders (esp. for NIH users!), so please check those locations in the beginning.

The current Message Board discussion threads have been migrated to the new framework. The current Message Board will remain visible, but read-only, for a little while.

Sincerely, AFNI HQ

History of AFNI updates  

|
February 06, 2022 11:14AM
Oh, thank you for looking at this (and the other one) during weekend!

This is an NHP dataset which gives me a lot of trouble with EPI-anat alignment. Like I said in the other post, I am basically following MACAQUE_DEMO_REST so I am going to standard (NMT2.1) space, using animal_warper, now possibly adding another anat step, as described in the other post.

At some point, I spent a lot of time tuning epi-anat alignment (but using MIN_OUTLIER) but even in relatively successful attempts, one or two epi dsets would fail to align. And these were different dsets depending on the parameters, so it wasn't that I had two completely bad datasets. Daniel Glen suggested using EPI[0] for epi-anat alignement, with the logic that a pre-steady state image has better contrast. I should also have said that the EPIs are collected with MION, which changes contrast compared to regular EPIs.

This worked fine (well, better than before), so I used EPI[0] for volreg and EPI-anat alignement.

Just recently I had a thought that maybe EPI[0] is good for anat but not ideal for volreg,

In afni_proc help I found

The entire purpose of -align_epi_ext_dset is for the case where the
user might want to align the anat to a different volume than what is
used for the EPI (e.g. align anat to a pre-steady state TR but the EPI
to a steady state one).

and

The user might want to align to an EPI volume that is not in the
processing stream in the case where there is not sufficient EPI
contrast left after the magnetization has reached a steady state.
Perhaps volume 0 has sufficient contrast for alignment, but is not
appropriate for analysis. In such a case, the user may elect to
align to volume 0, while excluding it from the analysis as part of
the first volumes removed in -tcat_remove_first_trs.

- which is exactly what I had in mind. So I decided to try that. But then I started having doubts about the "missing link" between the epi[0] volume and the MIN_OUTLIER volume, I could not find an answer in the documentation, so I thought I'd ask here.
Subject Author Posted

afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 03, 2022 10:58PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

rick reynolds February 06, 2022 10:55AM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 06, 2022 11:14AM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

rick reynolds February 06, 2022 12:25PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 06, 2022 12:28PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

rick reynolds February 06, 2022 12:31PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 06, 2022 11:26AM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

rick reynolds February 06, 2022 12:29PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 07, 2022 06:54PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

rick reynolds February 08, 2022 09:39AM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 08, 2022 10:01AM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Daniel Glen February 06, 2022 05:16PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel February 06, 2022 05:23PM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

rick reynolds March 30, 2022 10:29AM

Re: afni_proc: different -align_epi_ext_dset and -volreg_base_dset

Pawel March 31, 2022 10:51AM